Last month, I had the privilege of attending Harvard’s annual course. While
it’s impossible for me to summarize all of the material presented at
a course such as this, I wanted to bring you a quick list of highlights:
1) Genomics and Pharmacogenetics in the Physiology and Treatment of Obesity
As
scientists have unraveled the human genome, it is becoming clear that
the scientific basis of obesity involves not only our environment, but
many different parts of our genetic code. Scientists
are researching how different genetic causes can be identified, and how
they may respond to different types of treatment. Perhaps
with more research, we will be able to determine an individual’s
genetic makeup, and tailor specific treatments to that individual, such
as special types of dietary therapy, or specific types of
pharmaceutical interventions.
2) Medication Update
There are several clinical trials underway using various combinations of and new medications. An enormous amount of money and research is currently being conducted to find new treatment approaches. While none have come to market yet, there continues to be much interest in:
Endocannabinoid receptor antagonists (they block the receptor that is stimulated by marijuana) Rimonabant, Taranabant, and others. These
have been approved in several other countries, but continue to be
studied for safety here in the US. They can be helpful not only
with weight loss, but with metabolic syndrome and smoking cessation.
Combinations: Topomax and Phentermine (this drug is being called Qnexa), Buproprion and Naltrexone (Contrave), and others. I
have spoken with several patients involved in these clinical trials and
many report these approaches to be highly successful. Other
combinations including Amylin, Symlin, Leptin, with Phentermine or
Sibutrimine (Meridia) are being studied as well.
In
addition to looking at new medications and combinations, many
medications that we commonly use to treat a variety of conditions can
cause significant problems with weight gain. Often, there are better alternatives. Classes
of medications to watch out for include Corticosteroids (such as
prednisone), old antihistamines (like periactin, benadryl), Insulin,
Many anti-depressants (SSRI’s like Paxil, Tri-Cyclic Antidepressants
like Elavil / Amitryptilene), many anti-psychotics (such as Zyprexa),
and many Anti-Convulsants (used in the management of seizure
disorders), and Mood Stabilizers (like Lithium, Depakote, Tegretol). Sometimes medications can be substituted for those that cause weight gain and can help a patient with weight management.
3) Behavioral Strategies
There were several discussions on the benefits of nutritional counseling for long-term weight control. Clearly this is helpful for weight loss, but so many people have trouble maintaining a weight loss. Long-term accountability does appear to be an excellent tool for long-term success. Data
was presented from DPP (Diabetes Prevention Program) emphasizing that
Lifestyle Intervention for patients at risk for Diabetes resulted in
58% reduction in risk for diabetes. Look
AHEAD is an ongoing trial with 5145 type 2 diabetics enrolled in a
lifestyle modification program involving 6 months of weekly meetings,
followed by long-term supervision. Early
data is already showing significant improvements in diabetes control
and sustained weight loss. It has certainly been our experience
at CNC that our programs are extremely effective in obtaining good
control of Diabetes, and often weight loss enables us to use fewer
medications.
Other lecturers discussed methods to prevent regain. Specifically,
every-other week accountability for many can be very helpful, continued
physical activity (200 plus minutes per week), long-term medications
when needed, and perhaps long-term partial meal replacement. These presenters went on to recommend weighing weekly while losing, but weighing daily for maintenance.
One excellent lecture was on NEAT: Non-Exercise Activity Thermogenesis. The premise of this lecture is that exercise only accounts for a small percentage of the calories we burn on a daily basis. How many hours can you actually spend at the gym during the course of a week? However, as we get heavier and heavier, there is a tendency to also become more sedentary during all of our daily activities. NEAT is the energy burned from these normal daily activities. For example, people who fidget all day tend to be skinnier than their non-fidgeting counterparts. Dr.
James Levine has been studying this component of our energy
expenditure, and presented compelling data that if we can be less
sedentary (move more) during the day, this is helpful for both
obesity treatment and prevention. The problem is that so many of us work sedentary jobs. He has started a company developing all sorts of contraptions to help people be more active at work. One
famous example is the walking workstation, where there is a treadmill
platform and higher desk integrated in to the work station for people,
so they can walk at a slow pace rather than sit at the desk all day. What a way to get your 10,000 steps daily! What can you do during your work day to be less sedentary? He argues that NEAT can vary over 2000 calories / day between individuals.
Other behavioral recommendations:
Focus on achievable / sustainable weight loss
One size does NOT fit all
Try not to set unachievable goals
Understand your biological limits
Focus on non-weight outcomes (improved quality of life, longevity, health, etc)
4) Herbal therapies and CAM (Complimentary and Alternative Medicine) in the treatment of obesity
This topic is quite easy to summarize: there are no herbal therapies or dietary supplements that have been proven safe and effective in the treatment of obesity. While
herbal therapies and CAM do play an important role for many people in
their health and wellness and even in the treatment of certain
diseases, to date, there has yet to be any good evidence on the use of
these therapies for weight loss. Further,
many popular alternatives have been shown to cause harm and have been
withdrawn from the market (such as ephedra/caffeine combinations). However, it is important to include physical, emotional, mental, and spiritual aspects of a healthcare plan. For example, stress, insomnia, and depression management can play an important role in the treatment of obesity.
5) Physiological Adaptations to Weight Loss
This is a fascinating topic. Why it is hard to lose weight and maintain weight loss? There is a lot of thought now regarding our bodies establishing a “set point†for weight. Trying
to move too far from this set point can set in motion a variety of
responses designed to return the body to its starting point. There
is thought that this theory can explain why maintaining weight
loss can be so difficult, and a lot of research looking at how to move
this “set point.†George Blackburn, one of the
leading minds in the field of Obesity and the lead organizer of the
conference, has published a book, "Breaking through your set point"
discussing these theories at greater length, and is next up on my
reading list - watch for a brief book report from me on this one in the
coming months.
Clinical Nutrition Center: Where does all of this leave us?
At
CNC, we have always approached the treatment of overweight and obesity
one patient at a time. Our years of experience have clearly shown
us that every individual is unique. Over and over, my patients
who are successfully keeping weight off tell me the same thing:
"I focus now on the lifestyle, not on a diet."
I
firmly believe this to be one of the most important keys in weight
management. All too often, the cause of the weight problem is
staring us in the face, but the patient is unable to make changes in
this important area. Examples include: working too many
hours, medications with weight gain as a significant side effect,
untreated depression, relationship issues, business travel, lack of
physical activity. The list goes on and on. Often times
these patients will be very successful with weight loss, but without
changing the underlying cause of the weight problem, can have a
tendancy to regain weight.
How
can we prevent this? Clearly, long-term accountability is one of
the best tools to prevent going back to the old habits. Our staff
at CNC is highly skilled not only in meal-planning, but in really
getting to the root of the problem. Can you make changes to your
work environment? Can you discuss strategies with your dietitian
to arrive at the airport prepared? To eat healthy while on the
go? Can you work with Dr. Lazarus on changing to medications that
don't cause weight gain? Would working with a therapist such as
Mickey be beneficial with the relationship issues? Can you find
ways to be less sedentary during your work day?
Our
staff promises to stay current in the evolving fields of medicine,
nutrition, and obesity treatment. As new therapies come to
market, rely on us to keep you up to date as well, and to make these
treatments available to the appropriate patients.
Again,
each unique individual benefits from their unique plan of action.
Talk to our staff about what course of action will be best for you.